Mapletown won the second set to tie the Section 2-A match Tuesday night, but visiting Geibel Catholic won the next two sets for a 3-1 victory.
The Lady Gators won the opening set, 25-21, but the home squad tied the match with a 25-22 win in the second set.
Geibel Catholic put the win away with set wins of 25-16 and 25-23.
Kailey Stover had a nice all-around performance for the Lady Maples with six aces, seven kills and 11 digs. Macee Cree dished out 14 assists and Ella Menear had 14 digs. Sadie McCann finished with five kills.