Rendell’s plan for malpriactice task force draws praise
Dr. Lawrence J. Glad said he is pleased that Gov.-elect Ed Rendell has appointed a task force to address Pennsylvania’s medical malpractice crisis, but added that the solutions must be designed for the long term not a quick fix for the short term. Rendell recently announced that a special task force will look into soaring insurance rates that are causing some doctors to consider cutting back on services. Locally, a group that includes Glad and Drs. John A. Sunyecz and Christine B. Wilson stopped delivering babies on Nov. 1 because of a major increase in insurance premiums. Glad said if the practice had maintained the same type of policy, premiums would have increased from $150,000 to $400,000 per year.
“It’s not a decision we wanted to make,” he said.
Also, two orthopedic doctors in Uniontown have opted to take their practices to other states, claiming insurance rates were too high in Pennsylvania.
“I’m pleased to see that Rendell is aware something needs to be done,” Glad said. “I hope it’s not another quick fix. Let’s evaluate and make long-lasting changes for health care in general.”
Rendell has promised short-term relief on the eve of a Jan. 1 deadline in which many doctors face cancellation of their malpractice policies.
The task force includes doctors, hospital executives, insurers, trial lawyers and patient advocates and is chaired by Villanova law professor Abraham Gafni. The group will collaborate with health-law expert Dr. William Sage, who is directing a $3.2 million Pew Charitable Trust study of the problem. Rendell wants short-term recommendations by Jan. 20, the day before he becomes governor.
Nine companies have stopped writing medical malpractice insurance in the state in the past three years and doctors covered by the remaining three have been hit with rate increases of at least 40 percent this year.
Rendell has suggested a six-month suspension of doctors’ required payments to a Joint Underwriting Association that provides coverage to those unable to get it from a private insurer. The group will also look at authorizing physicians to negotiate jointly to obtain more favorable terms. Glad said operating without insurance could not be done for very long, and he views that as a short-term solution.
Glad said the problem is not just the cost of insurance premiums but if there is insurance available.
He said it is directly impacting the ability of doctors to provide services, especially in rural areas when doctors are in their own practices and not affiliated with larger hospitals. He said he disagrees with an assessment by Rendell that placing caps on damages doesn’t work.
State Rep. Larry Roberts, D-South Union, who has been vocal about the need for tort reform, said he thinks the task force is an excellent idea.
“No one seems to know what the answers are, not the trial lawyers, medical professionals or the insurance companies. Maybe the task force will help,” he said.
John P. Gismondi, past president of the Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association, western Pennsylvania chapter, and current chairman of the medical malpractice section of the Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association, said he thinks it’s a good idea to appoint a task force.
“Anything that gets everybody together is a good idea,” Gismondi said.