close

Grandmother frustrated by probe’s pace in fire that killed grandson

By Jennifer Harr 3 min read

Mary Younkin has been hoping for justice for more than a year. So she was angry when District Attorney Nancy D. Vernon said she was responding to a request from Michael Ellerbe’s family when she expedited her decision not to prosecute the trooper who shot 12-year-old on Christmas Eve.

As the grandmother of 2-year-old Gerald Younkin, who was killed in a Washington Township house fire on Dec. 14, 2001, Younkin had hoped to see charges filed in that case long ago.

“We have been trying to get (charges) to come about for months. Our case should have been heard before (Ellerbe) was even shot,” said Younkin.

Gerald Younkin was one of three children, all under the age of 3, who died when a Marion Villa apartment burned to the ground. The two mothers of the children left them home alone while they visited another apartment.

Last May, coroner’s jurors heard the case at an inquest and recommended that the mothers be charged. Seven months later, in contrast with the four days it took Vernon to decide if she would prosecute the trooper who shot Ellerbe, Younkin said she has dogged prosecutors to find out when and if that will happen.

“I know I’ve called them myself over 100 times,” said Younkin, who has also made visits to the courthouse to talk to Vernon or child abuse prosecutor Jack R. Heneks Jr.

Unaware of Younkin’s frustration until Monday, Vernon said she called her and offered assurances that the investigation would take on high priority in her office.

“I didn’t realize or sense her frustration,” said Vernon, who has promised to have a decision on the case within two weeks.

“We care about all of our victims,” stressed Vernon.

She went on to explain that, unlike the Ellerbe case where there were no charges filed, prosecutors must make certain any charges they file against the mothers of the children are supported by facts of the case.

“You can’t look at all cases in the same way, so I thought they were understanding that we were evaluating the whole (case),” said Vernon.

Billie Ohler was the mother of Gerald Younkin and 8-month-old Rebecca Ohler, both of whom died in the fire. Margie Povlik was the mother of 3-year-old Tomas Long, who also died.

The children were left alone with Ohler’s younger brother, 14-year-old Shane Shipley, who was upstairs asleep when the fire started. He jumped from a window in the apartment to escape the fire and injured his leg.

Police have been unable to determine exactly how the fire started, but ruled out arson. After the inquest into the three deaths, jurors asked that prosecutors consider charging both Ohler and Povlik criminally. That could mean being charged with involuntary manslaughter, a charge that encompasses a situation where someone dies as a result of another person’s recklessness or negligence.

“For over a year, I’ve been hoping that justice comes out for these poor children who died,” said Younkin. “This has been going on too long and people need to pay for what happened.”

Younkin said she hopes that Vernon will keep good on her word to bring the case to the forefront and get charges filed.

“I spent Christmas day at the cemetery visiting my grandson. Try that one for a while. I realized that still nothing’s been done and it hurts. Big time,” said Younkin.

In the end, Younkin said she realizes that criminal charges won’t make the pain of her loss go away.

“But at least then I can say everything legal that should have been done would have been done.”

Starting at /week.