Coroner won’t allow recording of inquest into boy’s death
No cameras or recording equipment will be permitted into a Monday inquest set to investigate the death of 12-year-old Michael Ellerbe. Fayette County District Attorney Nancy D. Vernon said Friday that she met with Coroner Dr. Phillip E. Reilly and he decided not to allow audio or video recording or flash photography during the inquest being held in Courtroom 3 at the Fayette County Courthouse.
“It is at his discretion,” said Vernon.
Reilly couldn’t be reached for comment. However, in a fax to the Herald-Standard on Saturday, Reilly confirmed that no audio, visual or other recording devices will be allowed into the inquest.
“The bearer of same will be removed from courtroom 3 by a sheriff’s deputy,’ read the fax from Reilly.
The inquest is scheduled to shed light on the events that led up to Ellerbe’s death. State police, who have been mum on details while conducting an investigation, have only said that Ellerbe was shot in the back while fleeing from two troopers on Christmas Eve.
Troopers Juan Curry and Samuel Nassan, who chased Ellerbe after he wrecked a stolen SUV in Uniontown’s East End, are both represented by attorneys and will testify, according to the fax.
While police have not said who fired the fatal shot, an attorney for the Ellerbe family said he received reports that Nassan shot the child after Curry slipped on ice and accidentally discharged his gun.
The six-person jury listening to information at the inquest will be asked to evaluate testimony of all involved and recommend any additional action. Such action could include the filing of criminal charges by either Vernon or U.S. Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan. Vernon called on Buchanan shortly after the shooting and asked that she have the FBI conduct a separate probe to ensure a thorough investigation.
If charges are filed, Vernon cited concerns that outside video or audio tapes of the inquest could prejudice a criminal jury pool. She also said that having a video record of the proceedings could give a participant the opportunity to go over his or her testimony before any other court action.
“We want to ensure independent recollections in the future,” said Vernon.
The inquest, however, will be put into transcript form after the proceeding.
The decision to disallow cameras at an inquest is in conflict with Reilly’s usual policy. At a May inquest into the fire-related deaths of three children, television cameras were permitted to tape the proceedings. Jurors in that case recommended charges be filed, although there have been no charges filed as of yet.
While that proceeding was held at the county’s federal building, television cameras have taped other inquests that were held in a courtroom because a large number of people were expected to attend. Included in those was a daylong inquest into several drowning deaths at Ohiopyle State Park.
Teri Henning, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association said that the only requirement for inquests is that they be open to the public. She noted that it is an administrative decision on the coroner’s part to allow cameras at the proceeding.
With a list of 10 witnesses, Vernon said that the proceeding will likely be lengthy. However, she said that Reilly is committed to finishing the process in one day.
Space will also be limited.
Vernon said she has been contacted by an attorney that represents one boy who could possibly testify at the inquest. The attorney asked her for immunity for the boy. Vernon said she agreed to that. She said that the focus of the inquest is to find out what happened to Ellerbe, not to file charges against people who were not directly involved in the shooting.
Vernon declined to name the boy and would not specifically say if he was one of the people who participated in the theft of the SUV Ellerbe is believed to have been in before he was shot running from police.
Noting space limitations, Vernon said 99 people will be allowed into the courtroom. She said a fire marshal deemed that the number of people who could be safely allowed into the courtroom without creating a fire hazard.