Military retirees seek action from Congress to receive full benefits
Military retirees are pushing Congress to adopt House Resolution 303, known as the Retired Pay Restoration Act of 2003, because they claim disabled veterans who have retired from the military are not receiving full retirement pay. The current law, known as concurrent receipt, requires that military pay be offset by the amount of disability compensation a veteran receives.
If voted on and approved, House Resolution 303 would allow retired veterans to receive both full retirement pay and disability money; however, this resolution has been trapped in the House Armed Services Committee for more than 10 years and has never gone to the full House for a vote.
This year, though, a congressman from Georgia is spearheading a campaign to bring HR 303 to a vote in the full House. U.S. Rep. Jim Marshall needs 218 of his colleagues to sign a discharge petition, which would force the resolution to the floor, where it would then be voted on.
Three hundred and forty-five representatives co-sponsored the legislation; however, as of Thursday, the discharge petition had garnered only 201 signatures.
Locally, U.S. Reps. Bill Shuster (R-Hollidaysburg) and John Murtha (D-Johnstown) say they support disabled, military retirees, but both say they will not sign the discharge petition.
Shuster, who did not co-sponsor House Resolution 303, said a discharge petition should be used only as a last resort.
Roger Shoemaker, senior legislative assistant to Shuster, said the congressman is “totally supportive” of disabled veterans. According to Shoemaker, Shuster has decided not to sign the discharge petition because he believes “there is a better legislative solution.” Shuster wants people from the White House, Senate, Pentagon and House Armed Services Committee to work together and come up with a solution that would allow disabled, military retirees to receive concurrent receipt, Shoemaker said.
“It’s hard to say what solution there could be until everyone is able to get together,” he said.
Murtha, who co-sponsored the resolution, said he will not sign this or any other discharge petition.
“I have never signed a discharge petition,” said Murtha, who said he objects to the use of the petitions because they are used to circumvent longstanding congressional procedures.
“Our veterans have made tremendous sacrifices to protect this great nation, but it’s a constant battle in Washington to block the ongoing efforts to cut their benefits,” Murtha said.
Brad Clemenson, Murtha’s press secretary, said it is important for people to know that the president has indicated he will veto this legislation. According to Clemenson, Murtha believes that concurrent receipt will not be resolved until an agreement is reached between the Congress and the White House.
Nevertheless, disabled veterans who would benefit from concurrent receipt say politicians are delaying the legislation because of financial reasons.
Robert Hixson, director of Fayette County Veterans’ Affairs, said that politicians “are probably holding back because it would be costly.”
Hixson estimates it would cost the government millions of dollars if disabled military retirees were able to receive both full military and disability compensation.
“It would be so costly that I don’t see it happening, but I hope it does,” he said.
Military retiree Dean Wineland said politicians should not co-sponsor a bill unless they are willing to support it all the way. According to Wineland, politicians co-sponsor HR 303 because it makes their constituents back home believe their representatives are supportive of retired veterans with a disability.
“When a member of Congress co-sponsors a bill, it looks like they support it, but when it’s time to make it happen and put the rubber to the road, they back out by not signing the discharge petition,” said Wineland, who retired with a disability after 20 years in the Air Force and now lives in Donora.
Wineland, who is unable to collect both retirement pay and disability money, recently joined Support the Vets, an Internet lobbying group dedicated to eliminating the current law.
“For over a 100 years, veterans who are retired and disabled have had a portion of their earned retired pay, equal to their service-connected disability rating, seized by the United States government, and it’s not fair,” said Wineland.
Veterans like Wineland, who served in the military at least 20 years and retire with a disability incurred during their military service, are eligible to receive retirement pay from the Department of Defense and may also be eligible for veterans disability from the Department of Veterans’ Affairs.
However, concurrent receipt requires that military retirement pay be reduced by the amount of disability a veteran receives.
Hixson gave the following example: Depending on rank, a person who retires after 20 years in the military receives, on average, about $1,200 in retirement money a month. If that person had a 30 percent disability, he or she also would be eligible to receive $310 in disability that is not subject to federal income tax. However, since concurrent receipt prohibits a person from receiving retirement pay and disability money, $310 of their $1,200 monthly pension is forfeited. They then receive $310 in disability, which is not taxed. Veterans say they should receive retirement money and disability pay and that $310 of $1,510, not $1,200, should not be taxed.
“Many veterans say it’s unfair,” said Hixson, adding that he hears complaints from about four or five veterans a month. “There are a few veterans that concurrent receipt affects in Fayette County and there are tons throughout the state.”
Wineland said no one explained concurrent receipt to him when he agreed to join the military.
“My situation is the same as about 500,000 other guys across the United States,” said Wineland. “Had I known about this, I would have never joined. But you don’t know that if you’re injured you won’t be receiving your full retirement. They don’t tell you that until you’re ready to retire, and by then it’s too late.”
Dale Coughenour, commander of the Disabled American Veterans Chapter 58, said many Fayette County veterans have nothing to gain by concurrent receipt, although almost all think the current law is unfair.
“Most people don’t spend 20 years in the military,” he said.
Coughenour said many veterans are like him: They serve for two or four years and leave the military.
Coughenour, who served in the Marines for two years, receives disability pay for being wounded in Vietnam, but he cannot collect retirement because he did not serve 20 years. Thus, he is not affected by concurrent receipt. However, he said he still supports the legislation that would give disabled, military retirees their full pension along with disability money.
According to Coughenour, Fayette County has about 16,000 veterans, of which 950 belong to the Disabled American Veterans. Out of those 950 veterans, he said he knows of only one elderly man who would qualify for concurrent receipt.
Concurrent receipt has been a controversial topic since 1944, when the initial bill was adopted. Since then, it has undergone some changes.
Last year, Shoemaker said, Congress passed a bill that allows veterans who were wounded during combat to receive concurrent receipt, meaning that they can collect both retirement money and disability pay if they meet the following requirements: were wounded in war, received a Purple Heart, are rated as having 50 percent of a disability or greater and make less than $30,000 a year.
However, the current law does not provide for veterans who were hurt and unable to remain in the military; neither does the bill that Congress is considering.
Coughenour said the new law is unfair for military retirees who have a disability but were not injured during war.
“If you’re combat wounded, you can collect both and it’s not fair,” he said. “If you spent 20 years in the military and retire with a disability, you should also be able to collect both.”
According to Coughenour, no other federal retiree with a service-connected disability receives a cut in his or her retired pay equal to the amount of his or her disability money.
“Say you were only in the military for a couple years and you became disabled; then you leave and get a job at the post office. You’d be able to collect full retirement plus disability. You go into the military because you care about your country, but (the government) doesn’t care,” Coughenour said, adding that politicians are concerned about concurrent receipt only during election time.
“With elections coming up, politicians say they’ll do anything for you,” he said. “They’ll tell you they support the vets, but they’re just trying to get votes. It’s what they do.”