Masontown residents fill town hall to protest disbanding police force

Mike Washko, mayor of Masontown, addresses the crowd at a town hall he organized to discuss how the council’s efforts to disband the police force would affect the community and what residents could do to stop it. [Garrett Neese]

Masontown resident Brittany Watson said at Saturday’s town hall she was worried disbanding the police department would lead to more criminal activity in the borough. [Garrett Neese]

Robert Plavi, supervisor at Fayette-Greene EMS, tells the crowd at a town hall in Masontown how getting rid of the borough’s police department would lead to longer response times for police and emergency services. [Garrett Neese]
Around 175 Masontown residents packed a town hall held by Mayor Mike Washko Saturday to discuss how the borough would be impacted by the dissolution of its police department, and what residents could do in the next week and a half to stop it from happening.
Following an unsuccessful attempt to dissolve the department by vote in January, the council voted 6-0 last Tuesday night to advertise an ordinance disbanding it.
A vote on the ordinance is planned for Nov. 24.
Previous council meetings regarding the police force had been held in cramped conditions, with standing-room-only crowds that spilled out into the hallway of the borough’s administration building. To remedy that, Washko said he would be moving the Nov. 24 meeting to a larger venue.
Washko encouraged residents to sign up with the borough office by Friday to speak at the next meeting.
“Get on the agenda,” he said. “Make it a tough meeting for them.”
As mayor, Washko does not vote on regular council motions except as a tiebreaker, but can vote to veto an ordinance.
If he vetoes it, the council could override it at the Dec. 8 meeting with a supermajority — at least five of seven votes. The department would then shut down after Dec. 31.
In that scenario, coverage would likely be handled by the Pennsylvania State Police Uniontown barracks. That’s on top of a coverage area that includes all of the mountain area off Route 40, communities from Point Marion to Brownsville and nighttime coverage in Uniontown, said District Attorney Mike Aubele.
“I think their typical response time to this area is going to be anywhere from 15 to 25 minutes,” he said.
Robert Plavi, supervisor at Fayette-Greene EMS, said because of safety concerns, a delay in police response would also mean a corresponding delay in patient care.
An incident in Masontown now has a response time of three to five minutes, Plavi said.
If that responsibility falls to state police farther away, he said, “it’s going to take them anywhere between 35 to 45 minutes to arrive on scene, which means we are going to have to wait 45 minutes to treat you.”
Residents said with the longer travel time, they worried about a slower police response in case of an emergency.
Brittany Watson said she worried about the potential for crime at stores and gas stations if criminals knew they had more time.
She said her children had also looked forward to seeing the members of the department.
“Our kids know everything that is going on,” she said. “They know that if they see TO (Chief Thomas O’Barto), they’re safe. If they see their guys, they see their girls, they know they’re safe, and that is something that sticks with them. They watch out the window, they watch them go after the cars that are flying on north Main Street, and when they’re not there, they just fly up and down.”
If the department is shut down and the officers disperse, that could also make it harder to prosecute ongoing cases involving the department, Aubele said.
“The reality is, that when we have officers leave either by attrition or we’ve had other departments that have closed, there are cases that go away sometimes,” he said. “Just in the last two years, we’ve solved a 15-year-old homicide that (O’Barto) is going to be needed to testify for. We just did an immensely large drug bust … and the Pred Hunter one that we just did. So that becomes very difficult for us if we don’t have witnesses.”
O’Barto told the crowd he had offered Council President John Stoffa his resignation on Tuesday if it meant the council would spare the six remaining officers for the remaining two years of their contract. Stoffa declined, he said.
Tuesday, Stoffa and other council members cited the need to put money toward a long list of neglected infrastructure projects in the borough. Although many of the projects are important, O’Barto said, he didn’t think eliminating the department’s budget would make much of a dent.
“There’s tons of projects that need attention, but you’re not going to finance a $5, $6, $7 million or more water plant for $485,000,” he said.
While planning ahead is important, Aubele said, for now, they should let him worry about what might happen after Dec. 31.
“if this council is elected for the right reason, if they’re doing it for the right reason, then they’re going to listen to you,” he said. “They’re going to listen to community, and they’re going to keep this police department. That’s why we’re here.”
Kathy Reed circulated a petition for residents to sign demanding to keep the department that will be brought to the council at its Nov. 24 meeting.
“Up until now, I really do not feel that they took us serious, and the more signatures, the better ammunition we have to produce and show them that we really, really do need a police department,” she said.
Some said they would be making phone calls to the council members, whose numbers were written on a whiteboard at the front of the room.
Others suggested protesting on public property outside the council members’ homes.
O’Barto told residents they could make their voices heard, but stipulated “no violence, no harassment.”
“As long as they’re peaceful, there’s not a lot I can do to stop you,” he said.
After the meeting, Masontown residents George Samuels and Charlene Livingood said they both planned to make calls.
Samuels said he would ask the council members why they wanted to shut down the department, setting aside monetary issues.
“That was brought up at the last meeting,” he said. “And what did they do? They ignored it and shut people down.”
Samuels said Saturdays’ town hall had produced a lot of good information, and he was heartened by an “amazing” turnout.
“We need to just pack this house (on the 24th),” he said. “That’s all there is to it. We just need to pack it and let them know that the majority of the people in this town don’t want to get rid of the police department.”




