close

Uniontown City Council approves strategic management plan

Consultants recommend city hire a manager

By Garrett Neese 5 min read
article image -
Rebecca Vargo, a consultant who worked on the Strategic Management & Transition Plan for Uniontown, briefs council members on the findings at a special meeting Thursday. The council later approved the plan. [Garrett Neese]

The Uniontown City Council adopted a report Thursday night proposing a wide-ranging list of changes to city operations in the face of what consultants said were growing deficits and deferred maintenance needs.

Consultants presented the findings from the Strategic Management & Transition Plan prior to Thursday’s meeting. The bulk of the plan, funded through the Department of Community & Economic Development, dealt with restructuring the city government and improving the city’s financial position. It also covered economic development and upgrading technology infrastructure.

The plan offered 50 recommendations for the city, split into short-, medium- and long-term goals.

Consultants said the city should immediately start moving toward a council-manager form of government, where the city council acts as the governing body and sets policy while the manager handles day-to-day administration of the city.

“The city is too complex to be run effectively through part-time elected officials and an overwhelmed city clerk,” said a document prepared by the consultants. “Hiring a city manager will result in stronger professional oversight of finances, grant writing, personnel, public works, police, fire, code and other municipal services.”

By 2029, the city is projected to have a general fund deficit of $307,000, said Rebecca Vargo, a consultant with D. Martinak Planning and Consulting.

Over the past five years, the budget has been steady, with revenues slightly exceeding expenses. The city has done a “tremendous” job of making do with what it has, Vargo said.

But taxes stayed static over the past 10 years, and the city has not put any money into savings, she said, noting that the city is heading into a precarious position.

Almost half of the city’s general fund revenue comes from the city’s real estate tax, which relies on an assessed value that has fallen for the past six years, according to a briefing prepared for the council.

“There is no rainy day fund, and so you’re left in a position where if there is a problem, if you spring a leak in the building, if you need a new HVAC, if you need a new fire truck, there are no funds available for those types of things,” Vargo said.

Vargo also highlighted the city’s spending on public safety, split between police and fire protection. It makes up 72% of the budget, nearly twice the share devoted to it by other municipalities in the county.

The report recommended renegotiating portions of the firefighter contract, such as the ability to cash in unused vacation days. Within the next year, the report said, the city should also request a peer review of the police department from the DCED, to reorganize the department in the wake of shrinking numbers and the loss of the city’s booking station.

The department had gone from 25 members to 12 between July and the end of the year, the report said.

“Police recruitment right now, and I’m not telling you anything you don’t know, is very, very difficult,” Vargo said.

Higher starting wages could attract more officers, Vargo said. The department’s starting pay is $54,995, well below the state median of $62,298.

The report recommended eliminating the minimum-manning clause, which requires a certain number of police and fire officers on duty at all times, which consultants said would drastically reduce overtime payments.

Other recommendations looked at ways to improve revenue, such as contracting with the Southwestern Regional Tax Bureau to collect residence taxes, and reviewing the list of tax-exempt properties on an annual basis.

Long-term tasks include commissioning a study to consolidate city facilities; the study also suggested merging two fire stations half a mile apart. To reduce maintenance expenses, the city could also look at transferring sewer lines to the county Water Authority, the report said.

For economic development, consultants recommended adopting some of the action items in the city’s comprehensive plan update, such as updating the city’s zoning and subdivision ordinances.

Proposed technology upgrades included replacing older hardware, moving to a central server and upgrading cybersecurity.

Thursday’s adoption of the report is only the first phase of implementing the plan, said George Newsome, DCED policy specialist for Southwestern Pennsylvania.

He talked about scheduling a workshop before a future council meeting where he could talk to council members about which items in the report they want to pursue. Those projects could then become future phases.

“I like to consider us as an information highway,” he said. “You guys ultimately have to decide what you want to do with the information and how you want to prioritize the recommendations based on what you see and what you’ve heard.”

Mayor Bill Gerke said the report had been “very helpful.”

“A lot of good recommendations, some we can immediately start doing, and then other ones that will take some time,” he said.

Councilman John Schoener agreed with many of the report recommendations, despite its “not glowing” picture of the city.

“I think we need to press forward almost immediately to start with DCED to get the grant necessary to take care of the city manager, because I think that’s the first big step we have to take,” he said.

Starting at /week.