close

Rodriguez, Alley relationship goes past tipping point in WVU loss

By Spencer Ripchik 5 min read
article image - AP Photo/William Wotring
AP Photo West Virginia head coach Rich Rodriguez reacts surrounded by staff during the second half of an NCAA college football game against Houston, in Morgantown, W.Va., Saturday, Nov. 21, 2026.

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — Houston had the ball well within field goal range at this point to knock through a game-winning field goal over West Virginia. There was a little over a minute left in the game, and the No. 20 Cougars had the ball at the 13-yard line. At this point, with the game tied, 31-31, it’d be best if the defense just let Houston score. That’s what Rich Rodriguez was thinking, at least.

Instead, defensive coordinator Zac Alley called a play to create a stop. Alley’s defense had the stop, but Houston was just trying to run the clock to kick the game-winning field goal to win the game. The clock ran.

Rodriguez called his last timeout. He was furious with Alley. Rodriguez erupted, threw his headset, and yelled to Alley, ‘You’ve got to let them score.’ He was so mad; the white hat covered his eyes, almost coming off. Alley ignored him and just kept signaling. By then it was too late. Houston kicked the 23-yard field goal to win the game 34-31 as time expired. WVU has now lost three straight games and is 5-6 on the year.

If you take the video from the week before that blew up online and this instance, the relationship between Alley and Rodriguez is beyond unhealthy. Rodriguez said he was upset at the end of the game because of the field goal block, but that was just one instance. You could’ve asked about multiple throughout the game and season.

“We haven’t played defense all year,” Rodriguez said. “In a few stretches, we’ll be okay, but not consistently.”

Sure, the offense stalled in the fourth quarter, and the injury to quarterback Michael Hawkisn Jr., with five minutes left, didn’t help, but the defense still didn’t do its part. The Mountaineers’ defense allowed Houston to rack up 490 yards of offense (might actually improve the season average) and 34 points.

There were blown coverages, and running back Mahki Hughes ran all over the defense, exposing the tackling. Hughes had a big 71-yard rush and tallied 158 yards and three touchdowns. He averaged 8.3 yards per carry. WVU’s defense allowed six plays over 20 yards.

“It seemed like when we missed an open-field tackles, it was a 40-yard, 50-yard, it wasn’t pretty,” Rodriguez said.

The kicker is that WVU’s defense was playing against the Cougars’ backup quarterback. Just minutes before the game, Houston starting quarterback Conner Weigman was ruled out after appearing on the injury report Friday night. Rodriguez said he didn’t know Weigman had an injury designation.

Instead, the Mountaineers faced true freshman quarterback Keisean Henderson in his first career start. To be fair, Henderson isnt’ you’re average true freshman. He was the top quarterback and player in the 2026 class as a 5-star. Still, it was his debut on the road.

Henderson led his team to a victory and completed 18-for-28 passes, throwing for 268 yards and a touchdown. His first pass was on the first drive, and it was a 68-yard strike to Amare Thomas over the middle of the field for a touchdown. There wasn’t a player within 10 yards of Thomas, who is the best weapon on the team.

There was just no pressure on the quarterback, which should’ve been a given against a true freshman in his first start. The defense sacked him three times.

“I thought he played pretty composed for a young guy,” Rodriguez said. “But we didn’t get any pressure on the quarterback. We got a couple of blitzes, got a little pressure on him. But outside of that, there is way too much time to throw the ball.”

WVU’s defense had its flashes against a top 20 team. The Mountaineers forced six punts in the game and had three three-and-outs. It’s improving, but like Rodriguez has said multiple times, it can’t get any worse.

In the fourth quarter, when it mattered most, the defense broke down. WVU allowed 10 points and 132 yards. Henderson completed a 12-yard pass to put the Mountaineers well into field goal range. Rodriguez wasn’t happy with Alley after that play either.

The game wasn’t all on the defense, but it seems like it’s well past its tipping point. The Mountaineers have just one more game this season against No. 2 Utah. The Utes are the best team in the Big 12 and have one of the best offenses. It won’t get any better and could very well be stomping on the road.

But at this point, it seems the writing is on the wall, and changes will be made once the season ends on Friday night.

“I think we got players that can play better defensively,” Rodriguez said. “Until I watch the film and see where the breakdowns were. Some of those, it’s just deflating.”

Starting at /week.